deviantART

 

For the Comic Book Stripper Contest, which would you prefer; decision by vote, or decision by judges?

65%
104 deviants said Voting's worked well so far!
35%
57 deviants said Judges would be preferable!

Devious Comments

Judging would be awesome and seeing as how i LOVE me some comic books and I LOVE LOVE LOVE me some strippers, i think it'd be fair if I was a judge...

(PLEEEEEEEAAAAAAAAAAAASE)

--
I make Fatty Beats to make you shake your fatty fat booty.
Judges are best, in voting wins the one with more friends.

--
Sorry for my bad english, i learned from watching movies and reading comics :D
Judges, because the general populous are whores who will vote for someone because they tell them to. I have seen many a nondeserving entry win due to someone saying "Vote for me my masses!" =P

--
Courage is resistance to fear, the mastery of fear - not the absence of fear.
Go with judges because of the exact reason the 2 people above me mentioned. It really seemed to me like the votes have rather been a popularularity contest. On a second note, shoudln't the entry win that you like most and not the others? o_O
Perhaps a combination of both would be for the best. How about this, there will be judges, but everyone can vote. Along with the judge(s) vote the public votes will add up to the equivilant of a judge vote. Like this:

Judge #1-voted for submission 3
Judge #2-sub. 4
Public poll-sub. 4

Winner: Submission 4

Something like this or something similar.

--
'We must temper the steel of the new generation...
We must surmount the blue majesty of the mountians.
We must look to the galaxy for our power...'
-Excerpt from "Black Flowers Called Sakinohaka", Planetes Vol. 3 (manga)
Personally I prefer judges, voting's too open to cheats who just get anyone and everyone voting from them without even looking at the other entries. It usually ends up as more of a popularity contest than an art one.

I did use a hybrid system on my contest for a while. I'd choose the top ten entries and then put them up for a vote. At least this way you can control the quality of the final selection.

--
Join the fun, join the Harem ~jessiesheram
Hey, it looks that the voting option have a lot of friends, The judges ain't perfect either, but are a lot better. Why people don't understand that?

--
Sorry for my bad english, i learned from watching movies and reading comics :D
I have a feeling a lot of people saying "vote" are folks who just want to see the results; everyone who's actually commented has said judges, and that's what I'm going to go with. :)

--
I'll stop thinking with my dick when you stop fucking with my head.

Pervert for hire! G to XXX! [link]

Beta Our Book! [link] Read! Fave!

Poll History

Site Map